Mamma Mia’s Amanda Seyfried Reveals Who She Wanted Sophie’s Dad To Be

The question of who is Sophie’s dad in Mamma Mia has never officially been answered. Even after the events of the sequel movie provided flashbacks to before Sophie was born, the question lingers, prompting a lot of fan speculation about Sophie’s father’s identity. Fans and cast members alike have their own preferences for who Sophie might have called “dad.” Mamma Mia star Amanda Seyfried reveals which one of Sophie’s three dads she would have liked to have been the biological father.