Why Sophie Doesn’t Return For Halloweentown 4

Despite being an integral part of the franchise, Sophie doesn’t return for Halloweentown 4. Played by Emily Roeske, Sophie Piper is Marnie (Kimberly J. Brown) and Dylan’s (Joey Zimmerman) younger sister. In the first Halloweentown, a young Sophie starts exhibiting signs of magical prowess: when she really wants a cookie, one floats through the air toward her. As Aggie later says in one of Halloweentown‘s best quotes, “Magic is really very simple: all you’ve got to do is want something and then let yourself have it.” Unfortunately, Sophie and Marnie’s mom, Gwen (Judith Hoag), is keen on hiding the family magic from her kids.