Alicia Keys’ Brother Cole Reveals What Caused Claim To Fame Cast To Pull Out “Their Knives”

On Claim to Fame season 2 episode 5, Cole was revealed by Karsyn to be Alicia Keys’ celebrity relative, and now he explains why he thinks the cast turned on him. Cole was one of the more quiet players in the beginning, and not much was shared about him. He became a close ally of Shayne. However, when he became the guesser in episode 4, he betrayed her in order to save himself. What he didn’t realize was that Shayne and Monay had already pieced together some clues, and figured out his true identity. When Shayne was eliminated, she left a final message for Monay to go after Cole next.